https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/namdeo-lokman-lodhi-versus-narmadabai-and-others/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/anglo-french-textile-co-ltd-versus-commissioner-of-income-tax-madras-4/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/cheruvu-nageswaraswami-versus-rajah-vadrevu-viswasundara-rao-and-others/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/workers-of-the-industry-colliery-dhanbad-versus-management-of-the-industry-colliery-2/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/mushtak-hussein-versus-the-state-of-bombay/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/election-commission-india-versus-saka-venkata-subba-rao/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/commissioner-of-income-tax-madras-versus-mtt-ar-s-ar-arunachalam-chettiar/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/strawboard-manufacturing-co-ltd-versus-gutta-mill-workers-union-2/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/in-re-the-editor-printer-and-publisher-of-the-times-of-india-and-in-re-aswini-kumar-ghose-and-another-versus-arabinda-bose-and-another-2/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/poppatlal-shah-versus-the-state-of-madras/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/saraswathi-ammal-versus-jagadambal-and-another/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/chhotabhai-jethabai-patel-and-co-versus-the-state-of-madhya-pradesh-2/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/commissioner-of-income-tax-west-bengal-versus-h-hirjee/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/ram-narayan-singh-versus-the-state-of-delhi-and-others/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/the-seksaria-cotton-mills-ltd-versus-the-state-of-bombay/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/buddu-satyanarayana-and-others-versus-konduru-venkatapayya-and-others/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/anglo-french-textile-co-ltd-versus-commissioner-of-income-tax-madras-5/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/maqbool-hussain-versus-the-state-of-bombay/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/hiralal-and-others-versus-badkulal-and-others/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/habeeb-mohamed-versus-the-state-of-hyderabad/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/bopanna-venkateswaraloo-and-others-versus-superintendent-central-jail-hyderabad-state/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/commissioner-of-income-tax-madras-versus-k-srinivasan-and-k-goialan-2/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/motipur-zamidari-co-ltd-versus-the-state-of-bihar-and-anoiher/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/the-state-of-bombay-and-another-versus-the-united-motors-india-ltd-and-others/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/bopanna-venkateswaraloo-and-others-versus-superintendent-central-jail-hyderabad-state-2/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/anglo-french-textile-co-ltd-versus-commissioner-of-income-tax-madras-6/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/dr-ram-krishan-bhardwaj-versus-the-state-of-delhi-and-others/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/keshav-mills-ltd-versus-commissioner-of-income-tax-bombay/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/ganpat-rai-hiralal-and-another-versus-aggarwal-chamber-of-commerce-ltd/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/commissioner-of-income-tax-madras-versus-mtt-ar-s-ar-arunachalam-chettiar-2/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/atherton-west-co-ltd-versus-suti-mill-mazdoor-union-and-others/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/payyavula-vengamma-versus-payyavula-kesanna-and-others/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/ganpat-rai-hiralal-and-another-versus-aggarwal-chamber-of-commerce-ltd-2/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/palvinder-kaur-versus-ihe-state-of-punjab/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/magga-and-another-versus-the-state-of-rajasthan/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/payyavula-vengamma-versus-payyavula-kesanna-and-others-2/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/rameshwar-bhartia-versus-the-state-of-assam/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/palvinder-kaur-versus-ihe-state-of-punjab-2/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/turner-morrison-co-ltd-versus-commissioner-of-income-tax-west-bengal/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/the-state-of-west-bengal-versus-subodh-gopalbose-and-others-2/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/the-state-of-rajasthan-versus-rao-manohar-singhjl/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/the-state-of-west-bengal-versus-mrs-bela-banerjee-and-others-2/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/anglo-french-textile-co-ltd-versus-commissioner-of-income-tax-madras-3/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/rao-shiv-bahadur-singh-and-another-versus-the-state-of-vindhya-pradesh/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/hem-raj-versus-the-state-of-ajmer/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/ebrahim-vazir-mavat-versus-the-state-of-bombay-and-others/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/sardar-soma-singh-and-others-versus-the-state-of-pepsu-and-union-of-india/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/minerva-mills-ltd-versus-their-workers/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/zamindar-of-ettayapuram-versus-the-state-of-madras/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/d-r-madhavakrishnaiah-versus-the-income-tax-officer-bangalore/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/chatturbhuj-vithaldas-jasani-versus-moreshwar-parashram-and-others/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/v-m-syed-mohammad-and-company-versus-the-stte-of-andhra/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/commissioner-of-income-tax-west-bengal-versus-messrs-jeewanlal-ltd-2/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/the-union-of-india-versus-madan-gopal-kabra/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/the-vice-chancellor-utkal-university-and-others-versus-s-k-ghosh-and-others/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/suleman-issa-versus-the-state-of-bombay/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/allahabad-bank-ltd-versus-commissioner-of-income-tax-west-bengal/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/d-r-madhavakrishnaiah-versus-the-income-tax-officer-bangalore-2/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/kalyanpur-lime-works-ltd-versus-state-of-bihar-and-another/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/messrs-dwarka-prasad-laxmi-narain-versus-the-state-of-uttar-pradesh-and-two-others/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/commissioner-of-income-tax-bombay-city-versus-the-century-spinning-and-manufacturing-co-ltd/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/the-union-of-india-versus-madan-gopal-kabra-2/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/kalyanpur-lime-works-ltd-versus-state-of-bihar-and-another-2/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/yusuf-abdul-aziz-versus-the-state-of-bombay-and-husseinbhoy-laljee/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/deputy-commissioner-hardoi-versus-rama-krishna-narain-and-others/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/satyabrata-grose-versus-mugneeram-bangur-co-and-another/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/jagadguru-gurushiddaswami-versus-dakshina-maharashtra-digambar-jain-sabha/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/the-rajahmundry-electric-supply-corporation-ltd-versus-the-state-of-andhra/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/minerva-mills-ltd-versus-their-workers-2/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/sree-sree-ishwar-sridhar-jew-versus-sushila-bala-dasi-and-others/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/commissioner-of-income-tax-madras-versus-k-r-m-t-t-thiagaraja-chetty-co/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/akhlakali-hayatalli-versus-the-state-of-bombay/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/allahabad-bank-ltd-versus-commissioner-of-income-tax-west-bengal-2/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/dunichand-hakim-and-others-versus-deputy-commissioner-deputy-custodian-evacuee-property-2/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/sree-sree-ishwar-sridhar-jew-versus-sushila-bala-dasi-and-others-2/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/n-arunaohala-mudaliar-versus-c-a-muruganatha-mudaliar-and-another/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/akhlakali-hayatalli-versus-the-state-of-bombay-2/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/commissioner-of-income-tax-bombay-city-versus-the-century-spinning-and-manufacturing-co-ltd-2/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/lala-durga-prasad-and-another-versus-lala-deep-chand-and-others/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/satyabrata-grose-versus-mugneeram-bangur-co-and-another-2/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/jagadguru-gurushiddaswami-versus-dakshina-maharashtra-digambar-jain-sabha-2/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/sir-kikabhai-premchand-versus-commissioner-of-income-tax-central-bombay-2/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/deputy-commissioner-hardoi-versus-rama-krishna-narain-and-others-2/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/natvarlal-punjabhai-and-another-versus-dadubhai-manubhai-and-others/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/the-commissioner-hindu-religious-endowments-madras-versus-sri-lakshmindra-thirtha-swamiar-of-sri-shirur-mutt/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/commissioner-of-income-tax-madras-versus-k-r-m-t-t-thiagaraja-chetty-co-2/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/chainrup-sampatram-versus-commissioner-of-income-tax-west-bengal/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/state-of-travancore-cochin-and-others-versus-shanmugha-vilas-cashew-nut-factory-and-others/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/lala-durga-prasad-and-another-versus-lala-deep-chand-and-others-2/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/mahant-sri-jagannath-ramanuj-das-and-another-versus-the-state-of-orissa-and-another/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/n-arunaohala-mudaliar-versus-c-a-muruganatha-mudaliar-and-another-2/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/chainrup-sampatram-versus-commissioner-of-income-tax-west-bengal-2/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/state-of-travancore-cochin-and-others-versus-shanmugha-vilas-cashew-nut-factory-and-others-2/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/natvarlal-punjabhai-and-another-versus-dadubhai-manubhai-and-others-2/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/himmatlal-harilal-mehta-versus-the-state-of-madhya-pradesh-and-others/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/cooverjee-b-bharucha-versus-the-excise-commissioner-and-the-chief-commissioner-ajmer-and-others/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/sri-sri-sri-kishore-chandra-singh-deo-versus-babu-ganesh-prasad-bhagat-and-others/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/habeeb-mohammad-versus-the-slate-of-hyderabad/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/m-s-sheriff-versus-the-state-of-madras-and-others/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/dalip-singh-and-others-versus-state-of-punjab/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/the-state-of-rajasthan-versus-nath-mal-and-mitha-mal/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/the-liquidators-of-pursa-limited-versus-commissioner-of-income-tax-bihar/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/sidheshw-ar-mukherjee-versus-bhubneshwar-prasad-narain-singh-and-others/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/ratilal-panachand-gandhi-versus-the-state-of-bombay-and-others/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/dalip-singh-and-others-versus-state-of-punjab-2/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/srimati-oramba-sundari-dasi-versus-sri-sri-iswar-gopal-jieu/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/anglo-french-textile-co-ltd-versus-commissioner-of-income-tax-madras-2/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/sidheshw-ar-mukherjee-versus-bhubneshwar-prasad-narain-singh-and-others-2/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/the-state-of-west-bengal-versus-subodh-gopalbose-and-others/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/m-p-sharma-and-others-versus-satish-chandra-district-magistrate-delhi-and-others/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/the-state-of-west-bengal-versus-mrs-bela-banerjee-and-others/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/chilukuri-yenkateswarlu-versus-chilukuri-venkatanarayana-2/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/habeeb-mohammad-versus-the-slate-of-hyderabad-2/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/duni-chand-rataria-versus-bhuwalka-brothers-ltd-2/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/general-family-pension-fund-versus-the-commissioner-of-income-tax-west-bengal/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/k-c-gajapati-narayan-deo-and-others-versus-the-state-of-orissa-2/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/surendra-singh-and-others-versus-the-state-of-uttar-pradesh/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/dwarkadas-shrinivas-of-bombay-versus-the-sholapur-spinning-weaving-co-ltd-and-others/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/the-sales-tax-officer-pilibhit-versus-messrs-budh-prakash-jai-prakash/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/the-commissioner-of-income-tax-madras-versus-mysore-chromite-limited/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/karnal-singh-and-another-versus-the-state-of-punjab/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/surendra-singh-and-others-versus-the-state-of-uttar-pradesh-2/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/biswambhar-singh-versus-the-state-of-orissa-and-another/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/the-sales-tax-officer-pilibhit-versus-messrs-budh-prakash-jai-prakash-2/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/anderson-wright-ltd-versus-moran-and-company-2/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/central-national-bank-ltd-versus-united-industrial-bank-ltd/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/sardar-indra-singh-and-sons-ltd-versus-commissioner-of-income-tax-west-bengal/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/dunichand-hakim-and-others-versus-deputy-commissioner-deputy-custodian-evacuee-property/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/automobile-products-of-india-ltd-versus-rukliaji-bala-and-others/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/the-commissioner-of-income-tax-madras-versus-mysore-chromite-limited-2/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/central-national-bank-ltd-versus-united-industrial-bank-ltd-2/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/sohan-pathak-and-sons-versus-commissioner-of-income-tax-u-p-2/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/commissioner-of-income-tax-excess-profits-tax-bombay-city-versus-messrs-bhogilal-laherchand-including-batliboi-co-bombay/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/thakur-pratap-singh-versus-shri-krishna-gupta-and-others/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/general-family-pension-fund-versus-the-commissioner-of-income-tax-west-bengal-2/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/commissioner-of-income-tax-bombay-city-versus-royal-western-india-turf-club-ltd/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/sardar-indra-singh-and-sons-ltd-versus-commissioner-of-income-tax-west-bengal-2/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/baburao-shantaram-more-versus-the-bombay-housing-board-and-another-2/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/naresh-charan-das-gupta-versus-paresh-charan-das-gupta/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/navinchandra-mafatlal-versus-the-commissioner-of-income-tax-bombay-city-2/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/commissioner-of-income-tax-bombay-city-versus-royal-western-india-turf-club-ltd-2/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/kedar-nath-bajoria-versus-the-state-of-west-bengal/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/dwarkadas-shrinivas-of-bombay-versus-the-sholapur-spinning-weaving-co-ltd-and-others-2/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/the-member-board-of-revenue-versus-arthur-paul-benthall/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/budhan-choudhry-and-others-versus-the-state-of-bihar/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/r-m-seshadri-versus-the-district-magistrate-tanjore-and-another/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/sukhdev-singh-sodhi-versus-the-chief-justice-and-judges-of-the-pepsu-high-court/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/kedar-nath-bajoria-versus-the-state-of-west-bengal-2/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/commissioner-of-income-tax-excess-profits-tax-bombay-city-versus-messrs-bhogilal-laherchand-including-batliboi-co-bombay-2/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/the-state-of-bombay-versus-ali-gulshan/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/naresh-charan-das-gupta-versus-paresh-charan-das-gupta-2/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/in-re-hira-lal-dixit-and-two-others-versus/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/sukhdev-singh-sodhi-versus-the-chief-justice-and-judges-of-the-pepsu-high-court-2/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/k-s-rashid-and-son-versus-the-income-tax-investigation-commission-etc/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/biswambhar-singh-versus-the-state-of-orissa-and-another-2/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/jugal-kishore-rameshwardas-versus-mrs-goolbai-hormusji/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/budhan-choudhry-and-others-versus-the-state-of-bihar-2/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/in-re-hira-lal-dixit-and-two-others-versus-2/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/the-state-of-west-bengal-versus-shaikh-serajuddin-batley-union-of-india-intervener/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/kshetr-a-mohan-sannyasi-charan-sadhukhan-versus-commissioner-of-excess-profits-tax-west-bengal/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/captain-ganp-ati-singhji-versus-the-state-of-ajmer-and-another/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/bhikaji-keshao-joshi-and-another-versus-brijlal-nandlal-biyani-and-others/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/r-m-seshadri-versus-the-district-magistrate-tanjore-and-another-2/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/harman-singh-and-others-versus-regional-transport-authority-calcutta-and-others/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/sahasw-athi-ammal-and-another-versus-rajagopal-ammal/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/pandurang-tukia-and-bhillia-versus-the-st-ate-of-hyderabad/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/gopal-singh-and-others-versus-ujagar-singh-and-others/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/hem-singh-and-another-versus-harnam-singh-and-another/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/raja-kulkarni-and-others-versus-the-state-of-bombay/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/sahasw-athi-ammal-and-another-versus-rajagopal-ammal-2/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/duni-chand-rataria-versus-bhuwalka-brothers-ltd/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/gopal-singh-and-others-versus-ujagar-singh-and-others-2/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/lakshminarayan-ram-gopal-and-son-ltd-versus-the-government-of-hyderabad/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/raja-kulkarni-and-others-versus-the-state-of-bombay-2/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/kshetr-a-mohan-sannyasi-charan-sadhukhan-versus-commissioner-of-excess-profits-tax-west-bengal-2/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/bhataraju-nageshwara-rao-versus-the-honble-judges-of-the-madras-high-court-and-others/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/the-dvisional-engineer-g-i-p-railway-versus-mahadeo-raghoo-and-another/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/lakshminarayan-ram-gopal-and-son-ltd-versus-the-government-of-hyderabad-2/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/harman-singh-and-others-versus-regional-transport-authority-calcutta-and-others-2/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/jagannath-versus-jaswant-singh-and-others/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/captain-ganp-ati-singhji-versus-the-state-of-ajmer-and-another-2/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/thaivalappil-kunjuvaru-vareed-versus-the-state-of-travancore-cochin/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/hem-singh-and-another-versus-harnam-singh-and-another-2/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/the-state-of-west-bengal-versus-shaikh-serajuddin-batley-union-of-india-intervener-2/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/mathalone-versus-bombay-life-assurance-co-ltd/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/bhataraju-nageshwara-rao-versus-the-honble-judges-of-the-madras-high-court-and-others-2/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/anderson-wright-ltd-versus-moran-and-company/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/suraj-pal-versus-the-state-of-uttar-pradesh/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/commissioner-of-income-tax-west-bengal-versus-a-w-figges-co-and-others/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/mathalone-versus-bombay-life-assurance-co-ltd-2/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/pandurang-tukia-and-bhillia-versus-the-st-ate-of-hyderabad-2/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/navinchandra-mafatlal-versus-the-commissioner-of-income-tax-bombay-city/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/k-c-gajapati-narayan-deo-and-others-versus-the-state-of-orissa/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/commissioner-of-income-tax-west-bengal-versus-a-w-figges-co-and-others-2/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/waryam-singh-and-another-versus-amarnath-and-another/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/the-dominion-of-india-and-another-versus-shrinbai-a-irani-and-another/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/the-state-of-madhya-pradesh-versus-g-c-mandawar-2/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/dajisaheb-mane-and-others-versus-shankar-rao-vithal-rao-mane-and-another/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/chandi-prasad-singh-versus-the-st-ate-of-uttar-pradesh/ https://legalsandook.com/sc-judgment/t-c-basappa-versus-t-nagappa-and-another-2/